SUCCESSION
"Ownership is not a set of legal rights, it's a
state of mind. You can't give people that state
of mind in one fell swoop. You can only nurture
it through education.
-- Jack Stack
Springfield Remanufacturing12
In private companies, the adversarial model of labor-management relations
is seldom so deeply ingrained as in the industrial giants which claim most
of the space in the media or academic theories. Bureaucratic layers of management
are not much of a problem. Founders often know all their employees by name,
and they know their spouses and kids too. (Despite this easy familiarity,
however, many founders are surprised at the result of confidential employee
surveys which expose the actual attitudes of employees towards the company
and the working environment.) Entrepreneurs are cost conscious not because
of some business school theory, but because they are spending their own money.
Yet entrepreneurial companies frequently do suffer from a distinctive
labor-management tension of their own: the very experience and stature of
the founders inhibit junior family members, successor managers and rank and
file from developing their full potential as decision makers, a process which
includes the opportunity to make some mistakes. This is a principal reason
why only 40% of well-established family businesses survive the transition
from the first generation of management to the second.
Carefully implemented, the PRO-Productivity System (tm) is designed
to train the company to function as a self-sustaining enterprise which values,
but does not depend exclusively, on the unique capacities or secret knowledge
of its founding managers. The very existence of an Employee Stock Ownership
Plan can help attract and retain professional managers who are prudently
wary of tying their careers to a company without a succession plan. Menke
& Associates, Inc. frequently designs selective stock-based compensation
programs in parallel to the nondiscriminatory ESOP to assure that successor
managers are sufficiently on the risk of the company.
The ESOP permits founding shareholders to realize the value of their
investment in the company while they pass voting control on a separate,
discretionary timetable to the next generation of managers or family
members.
An Employee Stock Ownership Plan creates an ongoing, in-house market for
the shares of a private company. Founding shareholders gain the ability to
sell some or all of their stock at a pace which suits their needs. Under
certain conditions, sellers can even cash out tax free. Please
consult the Menke & Associates booklet ESOP Pros & Cons
to learn more about the process of selling stock to an ESOP.
Laying the groundwork for succession in a company is one of the most challenging,
yet rewarding tasks of a business owner. Justifiable pride results from
establishing a corporate system which survives and flourishes beyond the
immediate influence of the founders. Even younger entrepreneurs rest easier
in the knowledge that the company will continue to function if fate should
cut them short.
Back to the Index
Next Section: Reality Check
HOME | ABOUT ESOPs | OUR SERVICES | OUR FIRMTOMBSTONES | CONTACT US |